Best Padded Glove for Catchers

Do you get pain in your hand when catching a Baseball or Softball? If so, a padded glove that fits inside your catcher’s mitt may help.

This post examines the best padded glove for catchers available on the market. Our top pick is a high-quality glove that provides good protection across the palm and several fingers.

Read on to learn more!

Best padded glove for catchers ultimate guide for all inner padded gloves

Please Note: This post may contain affiliate links. See our disclaimer for more information.

Catching and Hand Pain

Let's talk about sting. 

And no, we're not talking about the lead singer of The Police. 

Or the pro wrestler formally known as Steve Borden. 

Sting the musician and Sting the wrestler

Not the sting we're talking about.

We're talking about that dreaded feeling of sharp pain you get when you catch a hard pitch right in the palm.

That sting.

It gets worse as you move up into more competitive leagues - naturally, because you catch faster pitching.

Not only is there sting to deal with. Catchers repeatedly receiving fast pitches can be susceptible to injuries such as nerve damage to their hand and injuries to their thumb, such as hyperextension.

What can be done to prevent these issues?

Having a high quality catcher's mitt certainly helps. 

But what if you need more?

Enter, the catchers padded glove (aka, the catchers padded inner glove).

What's a Catchers Padded Glove?

From the outside, it looks like a normal batting glove. But on the palm side of the glove, it contains reinforced padding typically on the palm area, thumb, middle and index fingers.

Simply slip on the glove, then put on your catcher's mitt. Easy.

Max Scherzer and Kurt Suzuki of the Nationals talk at the mound

Notice the glove former Washington Nationals catcher Kurt Suzuki is wearing inside his mitt.

Catchers inner padded gloves are an effective, low cost way to provide much needed relief from sting and protection from hand injury.

This article showcases our top catchers padded glove picks with reviews and images of each. 

Before we begin our reviews, please note some facts about these gloves that are helpful to know before buying. 

  • They are not sold as a pair. They are sold as individual gloves.
  • If the product says “Right Hand Throw”, that means the glove will fit on your left hand (e.g., the catching hand for right handers).
  • Regarding sizing, simply choose the size you normally would use for batting gloves. 

 

Ok, now on to our reviews. Keep scrolling for more!

Best Padded Gloves for Catchers

Best Overall: Team Defender 2.0 Glove

Team defender inner padded glove for catchers

Our top overall pick for best padded glove for catchers is the Team Defender Protective Glove.

It's unique for a catchers padded inner glove. Why? Because it has a built-in thumb guard inside of the glove. 

A thumb guard will do a better job of protecting the thumb from injury than a typical catchers inner padded glove.

The thumb guard on the Team Defender is made of a hard, tough plastic material, but it feels comfortable and fits inside of the thumb stall of catcher's mitts.

Additionally, the Team Defender glove has protective padding over the index finger, the middle finger, and the upper palm area. 

The material that this glove is made out of feels high quality. The stitching seems solid and should hold up for many seasons.

Lastly, this is a padded glove for catchers that many pros use, so you know it must be good. For example, Yadier Molina has been seen using it.

The Team Defender glove is for right hand throwers, meaning it fits on the left hand. It comes in medium, large, and extra large. 

Pros

Contains a rigid, built in catcher's thumb guard inside the glove

Uses high quality materials

The glove is very grippable

Highly durable

Used by pro catchers

Cons

More expensive than average (though it's still super affordable!)

Some users report it's a tight fit in the mitt. You may need to slightly loosen the laces around the thumb stall.

 

Check Price on Amazon

Check Price on eBay

 

Palm View of the Team Defender Glove

Palm view of the team defender inner padded glove for catchers

 

Runner-Up: All-Star Full Palm Inner Protective Glove

all star inner padded glove for catchers

There are a handful (no pun intended) of things we like about the All-Star Full Palm padded inner glove. First, we like that it’s very lightweight and comfortable to put on.

We also like that the padding is a bit unique. As you can see in the image below, there is padding at the index finger, at the base of the index and middle fingers, directly below that area, and across the entire palm and down to the wrist in kind of a heart-shaped pattern.

This padding set-up results in a more universal coverage across much of the hand and base of the wrist. It’s also designed to spread impact across a wider area.

The All-Star Full Palm glove is made of “goat skin” white leather with a stretchy sweat-wicking material on the back. It comes in at least four sizes, including small (for the younger catchers out there). 

For this glove, you should choose the same size as you would your batting gloves.

Pros

Lightweight, flexible and comfortable

Padding covers a wide area

Coverage extends to the base of the wrist

Leather material on one side, moisture wicking material on the other

Comes in multiple sizes

Cons

Does not have a lot of thumb protection

 

Check Price on Amazon

Check Price on eBay

 

Palm View of the All-Star Glove

Palm view of the all star padded inner glove

 

Honorable Mention: Palmgard Xtra Inner Glove

Fron of the markwort palmguard padded glove for catchers

Another product that we like is the Palmgard Xtra Inner Glove made by sporting goods company Markwort. 

It has a simple black, gray and white design, and contains generous padding over the index finger, middle finger, upper palm and thumb. The padding helps reduce sting on the most critical areas of the hand that receive the most impact when catching.

The Palmgard inner glove is pretty lightweight and flexible, with a leather material on the palm side of the hand and a breathable mesh material on the other side.

It comes in multiple sizes from small to XX large, so it’s a good choice for a wide range of catchers, including youth catchers needing some protection from sting.

Please note that this glove can also be purchased for left handed catchers (e.g., “Left Hand Throw), which is somewhat of a rare feature among padded gloves for catchers in the marketplace.

Pros

Very affordable

Good padding over the areas needed most

Lightweight and comfortable

Comes in multiple sizes, including small

Available for right and left handed throwers

Cons

Some users had issues with longer term durability 

 

Check Price on Amazon

Check Price on eBay

 

Palm View of the Palmgard Glove

Palmguard inner padded glove for catchers palm view

Catcher's Thumb Guards

We know that some catchers have pain primarily in their thumb while catching and that they may not be interested in using a traditional padded inner glove, like we reviewed above. 

In that case, we would recommend trying a catcher’s thumb guard. 

Best Catcher’s Thumb Guard: Evoshield MLB Catcher's Thumb Guard

evoshield thumb guard for catchers

Our pick for best thumb guard for catchers is the EvoShield MLB Catcher’s Thumb Guard

Like other EvoShield products, their thumb guard works using their “gel-to-shell” technology. 

Essentially, this means following EvoShield’s directions to mold the guard around your thumb and have it harden around the unique shape of your thumb. This whole process takes just a few minutes.

The end result is an incredibly hard protective shell that covers practically all of your thumb. 

The biggest challenge in using the guard is that it can be tight to get it to fit in the thumb stall of your catcher’s mitt. For it to work, you may need to loosen the laces around the thumb.

Pros

Made by EvoShield, a well-known and innovative maker of protective guards

Protects existing thumb injuries and helps prevent future injuries

The guard has a custom fit for your thumb

Good coverage around the thumb

Affordable

Cons

May be difficult to fit inside the thumb stall on a catcher’s mitt

 

Check Price on Amazon

Check Price on eBay

 

Brief Video on How to Mold the Thumb Guard

Thanks for Reading!

We hope this article was useful for you. If you have any questions for us about catchers padded inner gloves - or really anything catcher related - please reach out by heading over to the Contact Us page, or by sending an email to scott [at] catchershome [dot] com.