Best Youth Catchers Mitt [2018 Season]

It’s important to get your young Catcher a dependable, durable and well-fitting Catchers Mitt. However, finding that right Mitt can be a challenge, especially when you consider that a quick Google search of "Youth Catchers Mitts" will turn up a mind-numbing number of results.

So we’ve sorted through the options to help you in your search, and we've narrowed the big list down to just a few of our recommended choices.

See below for our top pick for youth Baseball and youth Softball Catchers, as well as our budget pick for each respective sport…

Best Youth Catchers Mitt

A Catchers Mitt is the most important piece of equipment that you can buy your little Catcher. It is their primary tool for catching the ball and for protecting themselves from wild pitches. It is something that – with a bit of care – will last them a long time as they grow and mature into the position.

This is why we advocate for parents to get their kids a high-quality Catchers Mitt made by a reputable brand.

The good news is that there are many Mitts out there made by good brand names. The challenge is to know which among them are better than average and worthy of your child’s use.

We wrote this article to do just that. Namely, to identify the top youth Catchers Mitts and to clearly describe why they are worth a closer look.

What Size Mitt Does My Child Need?

Catchers Mitts are unique when compared to regular Baseball or Softball gloves for a number of reasons. One is that they are measured by their circumference, not length.

Therefore, when you see advertisements for Catchers Mitts typically in the 30+ inch range, know that the measurement is referring to the Mitt's circumference.  

For Baseball Catchers 12 or younger, we suggest looking for Catchers Mitts that are sized at or around 32 inches. For Fastpitch Softball Catchers 12 or younger, we recommend a Mitt that's slightly larger - typically, 32.5 inches will work well.

Keep in mind that you can always pick a Mitt that's a little larger or smaller depending on what your child is most comfortable wearing. The user's comfort - as opposed to any particular sizing guideline - is what is most important.

Our Reviews of the Best Catchers Mitt

Continue reading to see our choices for the best Youth Catchers Mitts for the 2018 season, including our top pick for those on a budget. 

Our Top Pick for Youth Softball Catchers

Nokona Alpha Select SV2

A premium, top-of-the-line Catchers Mitt for young Softball Catchers

Our choice for the best youth Catchers Mitt for Fastpitch Softball is the Nokona Alpha Select (SV2, 32.5 inches).

Nokona is an American company that makes all of their gloves and Catchers Mitts in the US. They are known in part for making some of the highest quality Softball Catchers Mitts out there.

The Nokona Alpha Select SV2 is constructed with a mix of buffalo leather and high-grade steerhide requiring very little to no break-in time out of the box. It is a closed web, closed back Mitt measuring 32.5 inches.

Two characteristics of the Alpha Select SV2 Mitt that stand out are its light weight and its high degree of durability (ie, it can take a lot of punishment while still retaining quality).

The Alpha Select SV2 is made for youth Softball Catchers, and versions are available for both left hand and right hand throwers.


  • Made with exceptionally high quality leather (buffalo and steerhide)
  • Limited break-in time required
  • Very lightweight
  • Nokona brand is well respected in Fastpitch circles


  • As a premium quality Catchers Mitt, it's expensive

Click HERE to Purchase


Close-ups of the Nokona Alpha Select SV2

Nokona Alpha Select Fastpitch Youth Catchers Mitt Side View


Our Top Pick for Youth Baseball Catchers

Rawlings Gamer Series Youth Catchers Mitt

Rawlings Gamer

A solid pick for youth Baseball Catchers

Our choice for the best youth Catchers Mitt for Baseball is the Rawlings Gamer Series (GCM32PTB-3/0, 32 inches).  

Rawlings is a popular glove manufacturer known for building high quality gloves and Catchers Mitts.

Gamer Mitts are built with a full-grain leather shell and a 1-piece solid web. They are designed for smaller hands so they fit youth players well, yet Gamer Mitts still have the same shape and materials as Rawlings higher-level, professional Catchers Mitts.

It comes with extra padding around the palm and index finger to reduce the potential for stinging. Additionally, the Gamer also has a player break-in level of 20, meaning that it should not take too long to get the Mitt sufficiently broken in.

Note: Gamer Catchers Mitts are currently only available for right hand throwers.


  • Soft leather shell and liner
  • Extra padding around palm and index finger
  • Looks and feels like Rawlings' big league Mitts
  • Already 80% broken-in at the factory


  • Costs a bit higher than the average youth Mitt

Click HERE to Purchase


Close-ups of the Rawlings Gamer

Rawlings Gamer Catchers Mitt Youth - PocketRawlings Gamer Youth Catchers Mitt - Front View

Budget Pick for Youth Softball Catchers

Mizuno Prospect Select

The Mizuno Prospect Select (GXS102) is a good-looking Catchers Mitt made by a popular Baseball/Softball brand.

This Mitt measures 32.5 inches and has a well-built H-web on a full grain leather shell. It was designed to be worn by a younger female athlete, so it has a good fit with a comfortable, sweat-wicking inner liner.

The Prospect Select also comes with a palm liner to help reduce the sting of a fast pitch. Lastly, Mizuno developed a unique thumb cut hinge which is built into this Mitt, allowing the user to close the Mitt more easily. At a very affordable price, it is an incredibly pick for the money.

Note: This Catchers Mitt is available for both right handed and left handed throwers.


  • Very affordable Fastpitch Catchers Mitt
  • Durable leather shell with strong, comfortable internal liner
  • Designed to be easy to close
  • H-web is sturdy and allows for improved visibility


  • Internal padding could be thicker

Click HERE to Purchase


Close-up of the Mizuno Prospect Select

Mizuno Fastpitch Youth Catchers Mitt, pocket view, affordable youth softball catchers mitt

Budget Pick for Youth Baseball Catchers

Mizuno Prospect Youth Catchers Mitt, affordable youth catchers mitt

Mizuno Prospect GXC105

This affordable Catchers Mitt is a good pick for young athletes playing behind the plate. Though made with youth Baseball in mind, this Mitt has many similarities to it's Fastpitch variety, which are discussed above.

Built by Mizuno, the Prospect is a 32.5 inch leather-based Mitt with a two-pieced close web. It's internal design has strategically placed hinges allowing the Mitt to be able to be closed quite easily, which comes in handy with small hands.

It is relatively lightweight, with a soft liner around the hand and an added palm pad. It's hard to beat this level of quality at such a low price point.

Note: This Catchers Mitt is available for both right handed and left handed throwers.


  • Good quality-to-affordability ratio
  • Mizuno's Power Close technology makes this Mitt easy to close
  • Comes mostly broken-in already, right out the box
  • Lightweight and comfortable, unlike many cheap Catchers Mitts


  • As mentioned above, the internal padding isn't the thickest out there. You may want to pair it with a glove sponge or an inner protective glove.

Click HERE to Purchase


Close-up of the Mizuno Prospect GXC105

Mizuno Prospect Youth Catchers Mitt, pocket view. Affordable youth catchers mitt

We hope this review was helpful to you. If you have any questions for us, don't hesitate to reach out by heading over to the Contact Us page.

Thanks for reading!

Best Leg Guards for Kids & Youth [2018 Season]